There are 2 innings where I feel a starting pitcher is always venerable, the 1st and the 5th. In the 1st inning there are a number of factors, facing the top of the lineup, getting used to the mound, not yet warm, feeling out which pitches are working that day, unsure of umpires strikezone, that all contribute to the offence scoring. In the 5th inning, it is more just a theory of mine, I haven’t actually checked the stats to support it (Maybe this offseason I’ll break down the runs per inning for starters). It just seems like teams score more runs in the 5th and my thought is that the starter is pressing just a bit to try and complete the 5th and qualify for the win, so it is a mental issue. Does that mean only a pitcher w/a lead in the 5th is more likely to struggle? That is my thought. I would argue the 9th inning is also a good scoring opportunity given the starter is probably tiring by that point but there are just too few starters that actually pitch into the 9th these days.
I bring these thoughts up b/c the Jays scored in 2 innings off Richard. That’s right you guessed it, the 1st and 5th. Scutaro led off the game w/a HR. The Jays could have had more if not for a baserunning mistake by Rios (more on that later). After the Sox scored 2 in the 3, Richard was now pitching w/the lead in the 5th. The inning went BB, 2 run HR, 1B, 1B and that was it for Richard he got the quick hook from Ozzie.
Litsch on the other hand held the Sox off the board in both the 1st and 5th. However, his 1st inning was far from easy. He walked Cabrera to start the game on 4 pitches, gave up a 1B to Wise, after a FC he walked Thome to load the bases before getting Konerko to ground into a DP. In the 5th after just being handed a 5 – 2 lead he struck out the side.
In the 1st inning w/Rios at 2nd and 1 out Wells hit a ground ball in the hole between short and third. Rios made 2 mistakes on the play. First, he broke for 3rd before making sure the ball was going to get through. Second, once he realized his mistake he froze between 2nd and 3rd but by that point was halfway between the bases. Anytime you are on 2nd and a ball is hit on the ground to your right you have to hold your ground until you know the ball is getting through. Since Rios was already halfway he would have been better off just continuing on to 3rd or he should have headed straight back to 2nd. Instead Rios froze which allowed Cabrera to gather himself and by the time Rios headed back to 2nd Cabrera easily threw him out. At the least Rios should have tried to get into a rundown and buy enough time for Wells to reach 2nd.
It was not a good day on the basepaths for Rios. In the 5th inning w/runners at 2nd and 3rd and 1 out he hit a 1B to right and tried to advance to 2nd on the throw home. However, since there was only 1 out and the ball was hit in the air to the OF, there was no way Scutaro was going to be able to score from 2nd and therefore no reason to try and force the opposition to cut the ball off. There are 2 reasons to try for 2nd on a throw to the plate. One, it is a high throw that will go over the cutoff man’s head or two, there will be a close play at the plate and you want the team to cut the ball off allowing the run to score, effectively trading an out for a run. This case was neither.
Rios’ troubles weren’t over yet. The 1B Konerko was the one to cut the throw off and he threw to the SS Cabrera covering 2nd. On the throw Konerko hurt something and went down. Cabrera chased Rios back towards first before throwing to the 2B Ramirez who was backing up first. Ramirez chased Rios towards 2nd and threw back to Cabrera at which point he peeled off. Cabrera started chasing Rios back to 1st, but the only problem was nobody was covering 1st leaving it open for Rios and it looked like Rios would make it back safely. As Rios was only a few feet from the bag he stumbled and fell face first short of the bag allowing Cabrera to easily tag him out.
For the White Sox there should have been someone covering first base. It couldn’t be the catcher b/c he had to stay at home in case Scutaro tried to score from 3rd. Likewise the third basemen had to stay at 3rd to hold Scutaro there. The pitcher would be an option but he was already behind home plate, as he should be to backup the throw from the outfield, and was probably too far from 1st to get there in time. The SS and 2B were already involved in the rundown and the 1B Konerko was on the ground hurt. That leaves the 3 outfielders. Meaning the RF should have been the one coming in to back up the play at first, regardless of whether Konerko got hurt. That is why on any play in the infield, outfielders should be moving in to backup any possible overthrows or as we saw the rare time an injury occurs. It is not like you can do any good standing out in the OF.
I didn’t get intentionally walking Rolen in the 6th w/a man at 2nd and 1 out. Sure it sets up the DP, but you already had a RH pitcher in there and its not like Rolen is tearing the cover off the ball this year. Why not just go after Rolen instead of expecting you can get a DP ball. Of course McDonald ended up hitting into a DP.
All said the Jays went 5 for 13 w/RISP and the Sox went 1 for 11.
I thought the Wells ground ball in the 1st in which Rios got caught between 2nd and 3rd should have been scored a single. The idea of scoring a play a fielder’s choice is that the defensive fielder could have thrown the batter out at first but instead chose to throw to another base to get a different runner. Essentially it means if there had been no one on base the fielder would have thrown out the batter, and therefore the batter should not get credit for a hit. However, in this case there was no way Cabrera would have been able to throw out Wells so if Rios had just held his ground (or if he wasn’t on base period) then Wells would still have been safe and it would be scored a hit. I think it was a little bit of hometown scoring, figuring no sense adding a hit to the pitcher’s line.
Milestone of note: Scott Rolen scored his 1000 Run tonight.
Moving to the stats:
Adv: Dye
P-Adv: Litsch (4)
Adv+: Rolen (5), McDonald (2)
P-Adv+: Russell 2
NAdv: Mench (6), Scutaro (6)
P-NAdv: Carrasco, Russell
DE: Scutaro (7)
ME(r): Rios 2 (7)
ME(f): Richard